2 Strangers Good Guy Bad Guy Puzzle

Advertisement

2 Strangers Good Guy Bad Guy Puzzle

2 Strangers Good Guy Bad Guy Puzzle
You meet 2 strangers.
One of them is a good guy who always tells the truth and
the other is the bad guy who always lies.
You don't know who is who.
So to find out you ask the first guy,
"Are you the one who always speaks truth?"
The mumbles an answer but it's inaudible.
The second guy says,
"He said yes, but he is a liar."
Which is the good guy?

Click here for Answer

Answer : The first Guy is the Bad guy/Liar, and the second Guy is the good guy.
Reason:
Even though the 1st guy mumbled and we do not hear the answer, the second guy tells us what he said. Now IF Guy 1 was telling the truth/good guy his answer would of been YES, then the second guy would of lied and said the opposite to his answer which would of been "He said No", but that did not happen. If you flip this around you will see that Guy 1 is the liar and said/mumbled "YES" which is a lie, and Guy 2 just repeated his answer and added the "But he is a Liar".